✕

IEBC under pressure as legal battles threaten 2027 election preparations

Politics
By Ndung’u Gachane | Nov 22, 2026
IEBC chairperson Erastus Ethekon. [Elvis Ogina, Standard]

Stakes in the 2027 elections could not have been higher, however nothing seems to be working in that direction. At least going by the bickering from politicians, the court cases and the stalled tendering process.

Stakeholders in the electoral process have raised concerns over the ability of the Independent Electoral and Boundaries Commission (IEBC) to conduct credible polls next year, citing shrinking timelines and the numerous challenges facing the commission.

With just nine months to the elections, the commission has no substantive chief executive officer (CEO), whose role in procuring election materials, recruiting staff and, above all, mobilising funding and other resources as the accounting officer is crucial.

The commission is also battling mounting legal challenges, including court orders seeking to stop the procurement of ballot papers and the recruitment of a substantive CEO.

The chaotic meeting IEBC convened with political players on Thursday also exposed weaknesses in its stakeholder-engagement strategy, with commissioners appearing to lack a clear plan for consultations and consensus-building among key political actors.

Time is running out as the contract of the current election technology provider, Smartmatic, expires in a few weeks. The company still holds election data, including the previous voters' register.

There are fears in political circles and within the commission that well-connected individuals have already identified a Lebanese firm known for conducting controversial elections in several countries.

“We want our proposals in cleaning the voters register, altering technology and decentralizing presidential results transmission taken into account,” said DCP leader Rigathi Gachagua, who also insisted on the livestreaming of results in audio and video format from all polling stations.

The contentious issues requiring urgent attention range from procurement disputes over technology and ballot papers to internal divisions, inadequate funding, staff shortages and allegations of staff victimisation.

Both opposition and pro-government leaders have sounded the alarm over the commission's preparedness. Opposition leaders accuse the electoral body of failing to consult them as required by law, while the ruling United Democratic Alliance (UDA) has threatened to boycott consultative forums, accusing IEBC of failing to take charge of the meetings.

This means the commission is still struggling to build consensus among political players, a key ingredient for the success of the electoral process, as all stakeholders need to be on board throughout the preparations.

It was, however, IEBC chairman Erastus Ethekon who raised eyebrows on Thursday when, appearing resigned and emotionally drained, he told the gathering that parties would struggle to conduct the elections if they did not sit down and consult.

He lifted the lid on the commission's dilemma over whether it would be able to conduct the General Election, warning that ongoing delays could affect its ability to deliver the polls.

Opposition leaders at the IEBC consultative forum. [Jenipher Wachie, Standard]

Speaking during his closing remarks at a stakeholders' engagement forum in Nairobi, Ethekon said pending legal battles  not only threatened the commission's ability to deliver next year's elections but were also a major bottleneck to the enhanced voter registration exercise scheduled to begin on January 11.

“We need technology to do voter registration, voter identification and transmitting of results. We floated those tenders in July and there have been court cases after court cases and administrative reviews at the Public Procurement Administrative Review Board (PPARB). We also tender for ballot papers, election is still manual, without ballot papers we can’t have an election,” he said.

One of the major legal battles hindering the commission from procuring election materials involves the acquisition of a new Integrated Elections Management System (IEMS), which has been challenged before the PPARB.

Interestingly, IEBC itself acknowledged an error in the tender and told the procurement review board that bidders had mistakenly been required to provide performance security equivalent to 20 per cent of the contract price.

The commission said it had identified the mistake and was preparing an addendum to amend the tender document, noting that the law provides for performance security of not more than 10 per cent of the contract price.

The disclosure was made during proceedings challenging the procurement process for the new elections management system, which IEBC advertised on August 11.

The challenge was filed by Galadirel Investments Limited, which has accused the commission of issuing a tender containing omissions, contradictions and unclear requirements.

Galadirel argues that the tender violates Article 227 of the Constitution, which requires public procurement to be conducted in a manner that is fair, equitable, transparent, competitive and cost-effective.

In its submissions, the company questioned the basis of the Sh30 million tender security requirement, arguing that the tender document did not state the value of the contract.

“The Applicant has perused the said Tender document and has found the following breaches; There is no value of the Tender provided despite the Respondent issuing a tender security value of Kenya Shillings Thirty Million (Kshs 30,000,000/=) contrary to Section 61 of the PPADA,” the applicant stated in court documents.

Through its lawyer, Julius Miiri, Galadirel further argued that the tender contained material omissions, contradictions, undefined requirements and incomplete provisions.

Opposition leaders Rigathi Gachagua, Kalonzo Musyoka and retired chief Justice David Maraga at the IEBC consultative forum. [Jenipher Wachie, Standard]

The company says the shortcomings could affect how bidders prepare their proposals and undermine competition, the evaluation and comparability of bids, and the equal treatment of prospective tenderers.

The contract of Smartmatic, the company that has been supplying technology to IEBC, is set to expire at the end of this month, a development that could leave the commission unable to conduct voter registration.

Sources within IEBC claim that commissioners are divided, with some pushing for an extension of the Smartmatic contract while others favour Miru Systems, a company whose operations have been marred by controversy in countries where it has supplied election technology.

“There is a deliberate scheme to extend Smartmatic contract by a section of the IEBC commissioners and some of them may have been involved in the petition; they want the expiry date to justify the decision to extend the Sh10 billion contract through a direct tendering process,” a source within the commission said.

The insiders say commissioners are also divided over the day-to-day running of the commission, with some accusing Ethekon of micromanaging the institution and making unilateral decisions without consulting them.

“For example, he has sacked four directors of Procurement in one month without consulting the commissioners; it is a one-man show at the commission, and this is really worrying,” another source said.

Another challenge facing IEBC is the recruitment of a substantive CEO, whom Ethekon says plays a central role in managing the elections.

“We need a substantive CEO to take us forward to the general elections because that is the person at the center of elections, that's the person who will help us to manage the secretariat and the technical bits of these elections to deliver a free fair acceptable election,” Ethekon said.

On Thursday, another suit was filed in court seeking to stop the recruitment of the IEBC CEO, with the petitioner alleging that the process was tainted by integrity concerns.

The Republican Liberty Party wants the High Court to suspend the recruitment of the commission secretary and chief executive officer, raising concerns over two shortlisted candidates: former Ethics and Anti-Corruption Commission (EACC) chief executive Halakhe Waqo and acting National Authority for the Campaign Against Alcohol and Drug Abuse (NACADA) chief executive Anthony Omerikwa.

In a petition filed against the State Law Office and IEBC, the party is seeking urgent conservatory orders to stop the electoral commission from proceeding with the recruitment involving the two shortlisted candidates.

“The Republican Liberty Party wants the court to issue conservatory orders restraining the IEBC and the State Law Office from proceeding with interviews, processing and appointment of the two candidates pending the hearing and determination of the application,” the court papers state.

Ethekon, however, appealed to stakeholders to be mindful of the strict timelines set out in law, warning that the alternative would be to change the election date, a move that would also require a referendum.

“The constitution says the date for elections. So we can't change that unless we do a referendum to change the dates of elections, so whichever way we are stuck with it. We need those institutions, for example the judiciary, to look at the cases filed against IEBC and to determine them within the shortest time possible because any inordinate delay will absolutely impact the conduct of the next general election,” he said.

He added: “If we delay to procure to determine the cases of technology that means we might not even conduct the next mass voter registration because we need those kits for us to configure them, put the necessary software to test them and deploy them to the future.”

As Ethekon turns his frustrations towards members of the public, lawyer Gilbert Njoroge, a constitutional and human rights lawyer who obtained orders in September this year compelling the commission to grant political parties and election observers access to the source code and audit logs relating to IEBC's continuous voter registration system, is headed back to court to file contempt of court proceedings against the commission.

Opposition leaders at the IEBC consultative forum. [Jenipher Wachie, Standard]

A ruling by Justice Gregory Mutai ordered IEBC to grant political parties and election observers access to the records to allow them to independently scrutinise the system and monitor its ongoing operations.

Justice Mutai issued the order pending the hearing and determination of a petition by Njoroge, who challenged aspects of IEBC's technology and its compliance with voter registration requirements ahead of the General Election.

However, Njoroge said that two months after the orders were issued, IEBC had refused to comply.

“I have written to IEBC over this issue but I will go back to the court and file contempt of court charges,” said the petitioner.

To support his case, Njoroge presented extracts from a KPMG final audit report on the 2022 voters' register, which he used to raise concerns about the accuracy and transparency of the current register.

According to the report, the audit recorded 481,711 registrations with duplicate or missing identification numbers, while 164,269 registrations had identification numbers that were invalid when compared with records held by the National Registration Bureau (NRB).

The report also noted that there were 246,465 deceased voters whose identification numbers still appeared in the register as of June 2022.

Some of the key timelines likely to be affected by the court battles include the second enhanced voter registration exercise, scheduled to begin on January 11 and targeting 3.2 million voters; procurement of an audit firm to audit the voters' register, scheduled to take place between February 15 and March 16; and implementation of audit recommendations, slated for March 23 to April 6, among other activities.

Opposition leaders, including Democratic Party leader Justin Muturi, claimed that IEBC was responsible for the strategic delays, arguing that its internal processes had also contributed to the setbacks. Consequently, they said, the commission had fallen behind schedule on some key targets set out in its Election Operations Plan.

Muturi questioned why key officials, including the CEO and head of procurement, were reportedly out of the country at a time when the commission was expected to be handling critical procurement matters.

He also claimed that the election evaluation tender had been put on hold to allow members of the evaluation committee to travel abroad, terming the development concerning.

“The commission is unable to demand expedited resolution of court cases and has suspended its own processes over officials’ foreign travel. The Commission cannot, on the one hand, plead with the courts to speed up cases, and on the other hand, freeze its own processes for foreign travel,” he said. 

Share this story
.
RECOMMENDED NEWS